| Register Now | |
| My Points | |
| My Games | |
Is there no option to search by forum specific location?
Anyway, Fall of the Jedi states, "Reaction: After your draw phase begins, place 1 card from your hand on the bottom of your deck." Does this happen before or after you draw to your reserve value?
If it is before then you might as well dump that last card in your prior edge battle!
Broken.
| Page 1 of 2 (19 messages) | 1 2 ...Last page » |
Badmojojojo said:
If it is before then you might as well dump that last card in your prior edge battle!
Not exactly… it allows you to run through your deck a little bit faster without having that card to be discarded. Maybe that will be a (small) advantage if we get to see any mill-decks in the future.
Without Signature
dbmeboy said:
OPTIONAL??? Where do you see that? It looks like a detriment to balance the rest of the power cards in the set forcing you to dump a card.
I was just wondering about the timing, as with all the cards that say, "After the beginning of [phase] do [this]" that is such a vague statment.
Broken.
Badmojojojo said:
dbmeboy said:
OPTIONAL??? Where do you see that? It looks like a detriment to balance the rest of the power cards in the set forcing you to dump a card.
I was just wondering about the timing, as with all the cards that say, "After the beginning of [phase] do [this]" that is such a vague statment.
It's optional in the way that all Actions and Reactions are optional unless they specifically say Forced (see Rancor).
Pg 25:
"Forced
While most card abilities are voluntary, some interrupt and reaction effects are preceded by the word “Forced.” Such effects must be resolved immediately whenever their specified trigger occurs as described in their effect text."
As for timing, it's pretty straight forward:
1. The draw phase begins
1b. Players may use reactions or interrupts to the draw phas beginning
2. You may discard a card
3. You draw up to or discard down to your reserve value
I think that is poor wording. Since it is always in play then it should have the word "may" added.
Broken.
Badmojojojo said:
I think that is poor wording. Since it is always in play then it should have the word "may" added.
Why when the rules clearly tell you that all actions and reactions are optional unless they say forced ?
For card search, deckbuilder, articles,podcasts visit: Card Game DB
Broken.
Badmojojojo said:
That does not make sense. You control Vader therefore you decide whether or not to use his reaction. Not your opponent.
For card search, deckbuilder, articles,podcasts visit: Card Game DB
Broken.
Badmojojojo said:
That does not make sense. You control Vader therefore you decide whether or not to use his reaction. Not your opponent.
Broken.
The choice of using the action is optional. Not applying its effect. No one said otherwise.
For card search, deckbuilder, articles,podcasts visit: Card Game DB
Badmojojojo said:
Badmojojojo said:
That does not make sense. You control Vader therefore you decide whether or not to use his reaction. Not your opponent.
Exactly. That is my point. Just because it does not say Forced does not mean it should not have an effect. Could not think of a card that worked as an analogy for a player affecting itself.
Vader's ability is entirely optional, as it does not say Forced. The DS player has the option on whether or not to use it when he or she plays a sith event card. The LS player does not have the option to ignore its results if the DS player chooses to use it any more than either player has the option to ignore any card text or game rule that they don't like. I'm honestly not sure if you're having trouble understanding how this works or just trolling at this point… if there's something about how Reactions work that is confusing you, could you please restate the question?
Broken.
How is it absurd to give players the option on whether or not to use the actions on their cards ??? To do otherwise would be absurd.
For card search, deckbuilder, articles,podcasts visit: Card Game DB
| Page 1 of 2 (19 messages) | 1 2 ...Last page » |