Search the Forums
Options
Keywords search:


Search in Forum...

Search within...

Match...

Antiquity...

Player messages...

Tide of Iron
A Game of World War II Tactical Battles
Moderator: ffgjafferGeckoThe SpaniardYourBestFriend Topics: 906 | Posts: 6333
Japanese Expansion?
Published on 18 October 2012 - 08:30:55
Page 2 of 2 (20 messages) « First page... 1 2
Reply #16 | Published on 31 January 2013 - 05:37:23
0
2

CrazyJones said:

I am waiting for the japanese expansion.  And too for an expansion that include Poland and France invasion.

 

We might see these at some point in time, I hope. My bet would be on seeing a Stalingrad expansion next: Days of the fox gave us half of a Bristish army (as compared with the sizes of the german and US armies in the base game) and Normandy provided us with the other half. Similarly, FoTB gave us half a Russian army leading me to think that a Stalingrad expansion would provide us with the other half so larger scenarios can be played.

known on most other wargame related forums as boersma8 (AAM, memoir'44, BGG etc.)

Reply #17 | Published on 02 February 2013 - 03:26:41
0
1

 

FoTB gave us a beautiful russian army with nice fun stats for their tanks etc. However, I still havent played with them, cuz there scenarios are mostly broken. I do want to play the last one at some time, but its monsterly big so its not the first thing which happens. I would be suppriced if they dont make scenarios which requier all the expansions at some time.

 

 

However, what I do want from a japanese expansion, is fanatic japanese infanteri, and real amphibius landings including some time in the water. Just imagine the bloody omaha scenario if the germans could

I) Fire at the US landing ships BEFORE they reach the beach.  If each landing transport includes two infanteri, sinking of any one of the would be costly.

You could include an extra random-ness for attacks at sea. A lightly damaged whatever sinks at the roll of 5-6 on a die roll. Maybe some infanteri could survive by swiming ashore. (cost 4 movement per hex)

II) all US infanteri in bloody omaha  enters the beach by movement or fire & movement action.

III) and just imagine the bloody omaha battle if not all infanteri apears at the same time. Would you then apply the same tactic for the US?

 

This would lead to bloody battles, and a lot of carnage even before the US has been able to fire a single shot. Obviusly the bloody omaha scenario would need to be rebalanced.

 

Another thing to include would obviusly be a US/Japanese combined air strategy deck.

A third thing would be jungle map. With no or little visibility.

 

But then, I'll rather take good scenarios over new stuff any time.

 
Reply #18 | Published on 02 February 2013 - 06:57:34
0
2

Grand Stone said:

 

FoTB gave us a beautiful russian army with nice fun stats for their tanks etc. However, I still havent played with them, cuz there scenarios are mostly broken. I do want to play the last one at some time, but its monsterly big so its not the first thing which happens. I would be suppriced if they dont make scenarios which requier all the expansions at some time.

 

 

However, what I do want from a japanese expansion, is fanatic japanese infanteri, and real amphibius landings including some time in the water. Just imagine the bloody omaha scenario if the germans could

I) Fire at the US landing ships BEFORE they reach the beach.  If each landing transport includes two infanteri, sinking of any one of the would be costly.

You could include an extra random-ness for attacks at sea. A lightly damaged whatever sinks at the roll of 5-6 on a die roll. Maybe some infanteri could survive by swiming ashore. (cost 4 movement per hex)

II) all US infanteri in bloody omaha  enters the beach by movement or fire & movement action.

III) and just imagine the bloody omaha battle if not all infanteri apears at the same time. Would you then apply the same tactic for the US?

 

This would lead to bloody battles, and a lot of carnage even before the US has been able to fire a single shot. Obviusly the bloody omaha scenario would need to be rebalanced.

 

Another thing to include would obviusly be a US/Japanese combined air strategy deck.

A third thing would be jungle map. With no or little visibility.

 

But then, I'll rather take good scenarios over new stuff any time.

 

Infantry should arrive with a move or move and fire anyway in Omaha beach. Now they just start with initiative and combine fire against a bunker or two and take them out.

 

I agree. Some more sea hexes would be great!

known on most other wargame related forums as boersma8 (AAM, memoir'44, BGG etc.)

Reply #19 | Published on 02 February 2013 - 07:00:16
0
2

Some much better balanced scenarios featuring the Russians can be found over at www.brummbar44.com (Red House and Factory Fortresses and more).

 

known on most other wargame related forums as boersma8 (AAM, memoir'44, BGG etc.)

Reply #20 | Published on 01 March 2013 - 08:33:02
0
19
Kingtiger said:

CrazyJones said:

I am waiting for the japanese expansion.� And too for an expansion that include Poland and France invasion.

�

We might see these at some point in time, I hope. My bet would be on seeing a Stalingrad expansion next: Days of the fox gave us half of a Bristish army (as compared with the sizes of the german and US armies in the base game) and Normandy provided us with the other half. Similarly, FoTB gave us half a Russian army leading me to think that a Stalingrad expansion would provide us with the other half so larger scenarios can be played.

At this point, I would be shocked to see anything else released for Tide of Iron. I'm not saying it couldn't happen, just saying I would be completely shocked to see anything new released for that game. I was looking at Lock N' Load years back, when I ran into Conflict of Heroes, which is similar and a very good game design as well. For me at this point in time, the element of time itself is very important to me. I've fallen back on the tried and true Memoir 44 game. M44 has expanded and added so much over the years, that game play has become a lot closer to ToI. One main positive for M44 is the different styles of game play it now offers. You can play a basic game in a little over an hour, or if you want something more, something bigger, you can play the Breakthrough or Overlord format. They already have a second campaign book out, and I think I have something in the neighborhood of 340+ scenarios to choose from, spanning every theater of WWII.

Young, Rodger W., Private, 148th Infantry, 37th Infantry Division (the Ohio Buckeyes) born Tiffin, Ohio, 28 April 1918 died 31 July 1943, on the island of New Georgia, Solomons, South Pacific, while singlehandedly attackingdestroying an enemy machine-gun pillbox. His platoon had been pinned down by intense fire from this pillbox Private Young was wounded in the first burst. He crawled toward the pillbox, was wounded a second time but continued to advance, firing his rifle as he did so. He closed on the pillbox, attackeddestroyed it with hand grenades, but in so doing he was wounded a third timekilled.
       His boldgallant action in the face of overwhelming odds enabled his teammates to escape without loss; he was awarded posthumously the Medal of Honor.

Page 2 of 2 (20 messages) « First page... 1 2

© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS