I think it depends more on how many players typically play in your games. If it's 5-6, Dunwich Horror is your best bet. Not only does it expand the real estate you have to cover, but it adds the Madness and Insanity cards, which add theme and actually make unconsciousness and injury more bearable (you don't lose items).
Upcoming game events:
* Game Kastle, Santa Clara, CA: Sundays
* Gamesday, Los Altos, CA
* FurtherConfusion, San Jose, CA