Search the Forums
Options
Keywords search:


Search in Forum...

Search within...

Match...

Antiquity...

Player messages...
You are here: FFG Forums /  Miniatures /  X-Wing

X-Wing
Take control of powerful Rebel X-wings and nimble Imperial TIE fighters!
Moderator: FFGStuartFFG_IanGecko Topics: 1428 | Posts: 17233
Rules Question: Swarm Tactics
Published on 22 August 2012 - 06:45:14
Page 3 of 3 (41 messages) « First page... 2 3
Reply #31 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 12:58:39

drkjedi35 said:

Below is the response I got.

Hello, Roy,

You can indeed chain the effect of multiple Swarm Tactics (ST). This is because you resolve your abilities sharing the same timing in any order you choose. Thus, Wedge can use his ST on Luke, then Luke can use his ST on Biggs. As a result, all three ships have a pilot skill of 9 until the end of the Combat phase.

Thanks for playing!

James Kniffen
Associate Game Designer
Fantasy Flight Games

I'm glad that this combination works.  I'll try it out once I have three X-wings and let you know how it goes.

 

Roy

Well, always glad to be wrong!  :D  This really changes things!  Now it's a viable (although dubious in quality) to take Luke+ST, Rookie+ST, Rookie+ST, etc, and just start moving the squad in formation like Blue Angels.

 

Granted, Blue Angeling limits your board presence, but in games where you don't really care about securing objectives and you're there to pew pew untilm the other guys drops, this sounds really funny.  That's worth a try or two this weekend.

Without Signature
Reply #32 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 13:16:23
4
7

Manchu said:

Also, now we know we're discussing the right topic tactics-wise by considering whether a three-fighter formation is worth more in a 100-point game than a two-fighter formation with the third flight member either serving as bait or providing cover.  That three-fighter formation is going to be much tougher to keep together.  In that case, maybe chaining will be more of a "hey, my starfighters happen to be close together" moment than something you count on while writing a list.

Methinks you hit it on the head there.  The "how" part is now settled.  Time to sort out the practical use on the table.  Taking the three ships and upgrades as stated just to allow that option is going to have to prove itself on the table.  Using Biggs as #3 in that list means it's probably only going to work for a single turn.  Staying in that formation would mean Biggs' special action will almost guarantee that he'll not be seeing the end of the game.  So that's one Swarm Tactics upgrade that'll go unused after turn 2.

Too bad its not possible to get two Named characters with swarm tactics and two rookie pilots in a 100pt list.  Giving two low end pilots high end skills while allowing them to move in pairs rather than in one bunch would seem to be more dangerous.

-DavicusPrime

VIR PRUDENS NON CONTRA VENTUM MIGIT

Reply #33 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 13:23:42
4
7

Stunami said:

Well, always glad to be wrong!  :D  This really changes things!  Now it's a viable (although dubious in quality) to take Luke+ST, Rookie+ST, Rookie+ST, etc, and just start moving the squad in formation like Blue Angels.

I don't think that Rookies have the option to take a skill upgrade.  Which greatly limits the type of army list available to you.  You'll have to grab two named characters with the skill upgrade option to be able to chain them.  So you'll have two high point cost models and your choice of one middle to low grade pilot in your choice of fighter to fill out the 100pts.  Not a lot of flexibility in list building nor in maneuvering to utilize it.

I don't think this will be a common combo because of that.

-DavicusPrime

VIR PRUDENS NON CONTRA VENTUM MIGIT

Reply #34 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 14:07:55

It probably won't be a common combo for the Rebels.  But remember that this can be done with Imperials also.  Vader and a few of the TIE Fighter pilots can use ST just like Wedge and Luke.  And they cost a little less.  Not saying that this version will be used any more than the Rebels.  Just pointing out the possibilities.

 

Roy 

Founder of  AFewManeuvers

Reply #35 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 15:46:15
16
1

 I don't know, I think it might be a real strength of the X-Wings to fly in formation. TIE Fighters seem like they're going to want to scramble, but a group of X-Wings in a nice formation could really solve that problem.

If you've got 2+ X-Wings staggered, then a TIE will very rarely be able to stay out of everyone's firing arc. Otherwise, I can see barrel rolls potentially allowing TIE's to fire with impunity a good chunk of the time. I know in the tourney vid, there were numerous times where, if instead of focusing or evading, he had barrel rolled, he could have slipped out of firing arcs all together.

Without Signature
Reply #36 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 16:12:43

 OTOH, Rory kept Luke and Garven in formation (regardless if by decision or chance) for pretty much the entire game.  Are you referring to escaping the Y-Wing and Rookie?  IIRC, he did barrel out of the Y-Wing's arc at least once.

"You can't win.  But there are alternatives to fighting."   Obi-Wan Kenobi on internet arguments

Reply #37 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 16:23:27
4
7

I was actually kinda surprised by the number of 180 degree turns both sides made.  The space combat games I've played before have been capital scale ships so I expected the usual charge and first exchange of broadsides followed by a swirling attempt at getting back into firing position.  I'm not used to having ships that can actually turn that fast.  And the Stress tokens didn't cause as much harm as I expected.  And that was probably due to the lack of variety they used with their action choices anyway.

This being fighter scale stuff, the head-to-head charge was followed by repeated flips instead of circling battles I'm used to with Capital scale games like Fire Storm Armada and Battle Fleet Gothic.  That's a mindset I'm going to have to retrain.

-DavicusPrime

VIR PRUDENS NON CONTRA VENTUM MIGIT

Reply #38 | Published on 24 August 2012 - 16:46:59
16
1

I think the dynamics will change a bit as people get more familiar with the two sides. The two sides should control vastly differently, and honestly, I can see flipping on the Rebel side not being nearly as useful against a swarm of TIEs that are controlled in certain ways.

If you focus the TIEs on the flanks of the X-Wings, the flip would be useless, and you'd really force the X-Wings to constantly have wingmen that are staggered rather than parallel.

Without Signature
Reply #39 | Published on 25 August 2012 - 20:28:49

Manchu said:

That idea of resolving simultaneously timed abilities in any order the controlling player chooses is bound to come up in other places -- just hopefully not where more than one player is involved (whose choice then?).

I'm near 100% positive that in the case of abilities resolving at the same time by multiple players, the player with initiative will resolve all of their abilities first.

What's left to be determined is who has initiative. We know that in the typical squad-building game (that most of us will be playing) initiative goes to the player with the lowest points. If tied, the Imperial player gets initiative. But as we saw at the tournament, there are many times when two Imperials face off. If two Imps both have the same number of squad points, who gets initiative? The answer to that question should also inform us on how initiative works in 2v2 games.

Reply #40 | Published on 26 August 2012 - 03:09:05
4
7

Budgernaut said:

But as we saw at the tournament, there are many times when two Imperials face off. If two Imps both have the same number of squad points, who gets initiative? The answer to that question should also inform us on how initiative works in 2v2 games.

Same scenario happens with 2 Rebs with equal points.  My bet is on a simple roll off if the usual deciding criteria fails to provide the answer.

-DavicusPrime

VIR PRUDENS NON CONTRA VENTUM MIGIT

Reply #41 | Published on 26 August 2012 - 06:45:14
2
3

DavicusPrime said:

Budgernaut said:

But as we saw at the tournament, there are many times when two Imperials face off. If two Imps both have the same number of squad points, who gets initiative? The answer to that question should also inform us on how initiative works in 2v2 games.

 

Same scenario happens with 2 Rebs with equal points.  My bet is on a simple roll off if the usual deciding criteria fails to provide the answer.

-DavicusPrime

Yeah I'd agree.  Roll, flip, thumb wrestle, whatever.

Without Signature
Page 3 of 3 (41 messages) « First page... 2 3
You are here: FFG Forums /  Miniatures /  X-Wing

© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS