Search the Forums
Options
Keywords search:


Search in Forum...

Search within...

Match...

Antiquity...

Player messages...
You are here: FFG Forums /  Roleplaying Games /  Black Crusade

Black Crusade
Wealth, power, and happiness await. The only price is your humanity.
Moderator: FFG Andy FischerFFGAntonffgjoshFFG_Sam StewartThe Spaniard Topics: 588 | Posts: 8170
Slaanesh: Perfection without corruption ?
Published on 09 May 2011 - 22:06:42
2
2

According to Lexicanum, Slaanesh is, among other things, the chaos god of Perfection. Which brings an interesting question to mind:

Take someone who is obsessed with creating a perfect {thing}, where the quality of a {thing} is diminished if it is tainted by the warp. After that persons obsession causes him to fall to Slaanesh, can he still create a {thing} that isn't tainted by the warp ?

Nugle loves me this I know.

Because the puss balls tell me so.

Page 1 of 2 (18 messages) 1 2 ...Last page »
Reply #1 | Published on 10 May 2011 - 01:40:10

I'd say no. Corruption is inevitable. The irony here is that this person would not realize the effects on the work he creates. At some stage, he wouldn't mind his art being tainted by the warp. In fact, he would revel in it, his understanding of perfection being changed and twisted together with his morals (and perhaps even his body). Chaos worshippers are rarely born with the mindset they have; they are being shaped into it. Artists are no different from any other kind of cultist.

current 40k RPG character: Captain Elias, Celestial Lions Tactical Marine

previous characters: Comrade-Trooper Dasha Malenko (OW), Sister Militant Elana Melanthis (DH), Leftenant Darion Baylesworth (RT)

Reply #2 | Published on 10 May 2011 - 04:03:36

 Alternatively, the artist might simply despair when he sees that it's impossible to arrive at his beloved perfection. 

Insanity ensues...

Ceterum Censeo Dezmond Ignorandum Esse.

Reply #3 | Published on 10 May 2011 - 12:57:02

Right, now that you mention it, there was something about it "never being enough" - a corrupted being will never be satisfied with what he has and will continually seek "the next step" ...

current 40k RPG character: Captain Elias, Celestial Lions Tactical Marine

previous characters: Comrade-Trooper Dasha Malenko (OW), Sister Militant Elana Melanthis (DH), Leftenant Darion Baylesworth (RT)

Reply #4 | Published on 11 May 2011 - 12:16:21

I don't have access to my books right now, or I would look it up. There was a "perfect work" heresy listed in, I want to say Disciples of the Dark Gods. I involved an artist/scholar being infected with an obession to work toward a perfect truth, only to have it cause a warp incursion when complete. If I am remembering this incorrectly, then I offer my apologies.

Chaos is the essence of the universe.

Reply #5 | Published on 11 May 2011 - 15:09:48
3
1

Alpha Chaos 13 said:

I don't have access to my books right now, or I would look it up. There was a "perfect work" heresy listed in, I want to say Disciples of the Dark Gods. I involved an artist/scholar being infected with an obession to work toward a perfect truth, only to have it cause a warp incursion when complete. If I am remembering this incorrectly, then I offer my apologies.

 

I belive it is the heresy of Ateanism you are speaking of, and it does indeed spark a warp incursion when a work (either of art or of science I belive) is completed, using the calculations and formula from the "eris transform", usually an incomplete one.

 

Though chances are I am completely wrong, it's been known to happen.

Without Signature
Reply #6 | Published on 11 May 2011 - 22:02:37
2
2

Lynata said:

 

Right, now that you mention it, there was something about it "never being enough" - a corrupted being will never be satisfied with what he has and will continually seek "the next step" ...

 

 

Slaanesh is also the god of excess, so I was planning that the next step would always include "make it bigger".

Nugle loves me this I know.

Because the puss balls tell me so.

Reply #7 | Published on 13 May 2011 - 07:39:15

Nightsorrow said:

Alpha Chaos 13 said:

 

I don't have access to my books right now, or I would look it up. There was a "perfect work" heresy listed in, I want to say Disciples of the Dark Gods. I involved an artist/scholar being infected with an obession to work toward a perfect truth, only to have it cause a warp incursion when complete. If I am remembering this incorrectly, then I offer my apologies.

 

 

 

I belive it is the heresy of Ateanism you are speaking of, and it does indeed spark a warp incursion when a work (either of art or of science I belive) is completed, using the calculations and formula from the "eris transform", usually an incomplete one.

 

Though chances are I am completely wrong, it's been known to happen.

That was it!

Chaos is the essence of the universe.

Reply #8 | Published on 13 May 2011 - 10:34:52

Bilateralrope said:

 

According to Lexicanum, Slaanesh is, among other things, the chaos god of Perfection. Which brings an interesting question to mind:

Take someone who is obsessed with creating a perfect {thing}, where the quality of a {thing} is diminished if it is tainted by the warp. After that persons obsession causes him to fall to Slaanesh, can he still create a {thing} that isn't tainted by the warp ?

 

 

I'd say it goes like this: Perfection is absolute, so the number of details you have to take into account (the number of perfectly crafted details you have to have in one perfectly crafted item) is actually infinite.

So when you set upon doing your Perfect thing you find, for example 10, imperfect details you must make perfect for the whole piece to be perfect. But when you start to make that one imperfect detail perfect you find that it consists of 10 smaller imperfect details, which each consist of 10 smaller imperfect details... and so on. Its like a fractal. The more you try to make it "perfect" the more and more "imperfections" you find to fix. The irony of it all being, of course, that the deeper you dive into trying to make it perfect the MORE imperfect everything seems.

Did you pass the sanity check yet?

Reply #9 | Published on 16 May 2011 - 04:07:26

Bilateralrope said:

According to Lexicanum, Slaanesh is, among other things, the chaos god of Perfection. Which brings an interesting question to mind:

Take someone who is obsessed with creating a perfect {thing}, where the quality of a {thing} is diminished if it is tainted by the warp. After that persons obsession causes him to fall to Slaanesh, can he still create a {thing} that isn't tainted by the warp ?

 

Sure you can, trust me. Just sign here and you'll be ready to go.

 

You signed up?

 

Alex

talentlesshack's Fillable DW Character Sheets: www.megaupload.com/
A discussion of how to convert 40K TT firearms to Deathwatch: www.fantasyflightgames.com/edge_foros_discusion.asp
My DW Gear and Solo/Squad Mode cards: www.fantasyflightgames.com/edge_foros_discusion.asp
Pre-RoB Crimson Fists Full Chapter rules (complete overhaul pending): www.fantasyflightgames.com/edge_foros_discusion.asp

 

Reply #10 | Published on 17 May 2011 - 15:22:27

The novel 'Fulgrim' addresses this idea quite well, the pursuit of perfection. The artists perception of perfection, obsession, and corruption. So in short, I'd say no...anything touched by Slannesh will be corrupted in the pursuit of perceived perfection.

Have you seen the Sign?

Reply #11 | Published on 25 May 2011 - 11:41:19
8
0

Polaria said:

So when you set upon doing your Perfect thing you find, for example 10, imperfect details you must make perfect for the whole piece to be perfect. But when you start to make that one imperfect detail perfect you find that it consists of 10 smaller imperfect details, which each consist of 10 smaller imperfect details... and so on. Its like a fractal. The more you try to make it "perfect" the more and more "imperfections" you find to fix. The irony of it all being, of course, that the deeper you dive into trying to make it perfect the MORE imperfect everything seems.

Did you pass the sanity check yet?

The joys of clinical insanity: not more sanity checks! Yipee for Tzeench and his convoluted- LOOK AT THE PURPLE BUNNY WITH FANGS RIPPING OUT MY THROAT!!! ITS SO CUTE!!!

life is not a box of chocolates. At least that has an ingredients list.

Reply #12 | Published on 28 May 2011 - 16:30:01

 I thought Slaanesh was the chaos god of nipples?

I will show you fear in a handful of dust- TS Eliot

http://wreck-age.net

Reply #13 | Published on 28 May 2011 - 16:46:16
2
2

msears said:

 I thought Slaanesh was the chaos god of nipples?

Among other things.

Nugle loves me this I know.

Because the puss balls tell me so.

Reply #14 | Published on 29 May 2011 - 14:03:03

Insanity.  Definitely insanity, since chaos is in and of itself inherently imperfect ('perfection' being a aspect of Order).

 

40k runs into a LOT of problems, both philisophical and logical anytime they trot out chaos on it's little leash and get saps like us to spend money on more 40k trash.  The first is that they should have gone for the full enchilada when stealing Moorcock's cosmology instead of just the lords of Chaos.  It would make a lot more sense.  The writers now have to ram aspects of both chaos and order into the four (five) chaos gods.  This leads to obvious paradoxes such as Slaanesh being the god of perfection (from a certain point of view).  'True' perfection is impossible in the grimdark future of 40k, as the warp underlays everything.  This has some serious ramifications if people ever thought about it (for example, how does anything ever crystalize then?  Or protine's fold?  Living humans would be impossible if the underlaying principles of the universe were as 40k claims they are)

Second: the idea of corruption as a willing surrender of self (even when it would be directly opposed to the goals of the person being corrupted) I know FFG had to coem up with soemthing other then Slaanesh = sex, but Ateanism ignores...well... even a lot of the internal logic of 40k.  The main problem is that the 'Lovecraft Approach' to the sanity blasting horror of the truth revealed falls flat in 40k because the idea that simply knowing something will turn you tenticaled and insane is more funny then squick at this point.  Call of Cthulhu really beat this concept to death years ago and it just doesn't work anymore. 

 

Non Nobis Domine Sed Nomine Tua Da Na Glorium

If the tanks succeed, then victory follows.
Heinz Guderian

 

Reply #15 | Published on 30 May 2011 - 09:46:10
1
0

Despite WH Chaos ideas being inspired from Moorcock's works, I don't think the first concept would be the same as the latter.

That is, WH Chaos, being quite chaotic, are not the primordial force of desorder, opposed to the primal force of order/law.

Chaos entities on Warhammer are embodiment of powerful emotions. That's why they're irrational. But having traces of order or stasis is not a contradiction to the concept, I think.

Milk for the Milk God!

Page 1 of 2 (18 messages) 1 2 ...Last page »
You are here: FFG Forums /  Roleplaying Games /  Black Crusade

© 2013 Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc. Fantasy Flight Games and the FFG logo are ® of Fantasy Flight Publishing, Inc.  All rights reserved.
Privacy Policy | Terms of Use | Contact | User Support | Rules Questions | Help | RSS